Register now to get rid of these ads!

Technical Catastrophic water pump failure

Discussion in 'The Hokey Ass Message Board' started by ibspector, Nov 3, 2024.

  1. My comment is that I have not seen that much damage on a roadster before. Maybe none had side panels but I hadn't seen anything other than radiator damage before. I'm glad nobody was hurt.
     
    Sharpone likes this.
  2. Unkl Ian
    Joined: Mar 29, 2001
    Posts: 13,419

    Unkl Ian

    I wonder how the material thickness, of the broken aftermarket fan,
    compares to similar OEM designs. Because you know bean counters
    like to make stuff thinner, to save 5 cents per 100 units.
     
    Last edited: Nov 4, 2024
  3. twenty8
    Joined: Apr 8, 2021
    Posts: 2,866

    twenty8
    Member

    I beg your pardon??? How rude. Our seasons are just fine. It is yours that are back to front.....:D;)
     
    lumpy 63, Sharpone and Driver50x like this.
  4. GlassThamesDoug
    Joined: May 25, 2008
    Posts: 1,756

    GlassThamesDoug
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    Big mass fan, pulley as mentioned.
    Add belt load pulling down.
    Fan is straightening lifting up fighting belts.
    Fan blade shows existing Crack signs. (Just saw previous post)

    Mohrs Circle... diagram..on loading after fan blade failure. Looks like casting failure started between lower bolts, high stress from fastener location.

    Improve, rebuild, get it back on the road.
     
    Last edited: Nov 5, 2024
    Sharpone likes this.
  5. GlassThamesDoug
    Joined: May 25, 2008
    Posts: 1,756

    GlassThamesDoug
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    Smooth to rough.... fan was cracked. Smooth is Beech Marks..existing Crack.
     
    chicken and Sharpone like this.
  6. 41 GMC K-18
    Joined: Jun 27, 2019
    Posts: 4,186

    41 GMC K-18
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    I bought this ancient belt driven fan, that was part of a water passage from some type of industrial engine, years ago at the Portland swap-meet.
    It has a bearing housing that is a oil reservoir. When I saw it at the swap-meet, it was just spinning freely in the wind.
    Paid $3.00 for it.
    It's just a cool unit that sits on my front porch, doing it's thing.
    The thickness of the metal on these blades, is testament to how well the old stuff was made, built to last a lifetime.
    Everyone's results may vary greatly!

    IMG_0318.JPG IMG_1220.jpg
     
  7. ibspector
    Joined: Dec 4, 2010
    Posts: 12

    ibspector
    Member

    It wasn’t the water pump.
     
  8. GlassThamesDoug
    Joined: May 25, 2008
    Posts: 1,756

    GlassThamesDoug
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    Heavy Duty like old farm tractors....
     
    Sharpone and 41 GMC K-18 like this.
  9. Blue Moon Garage
    Joined: Mar 1, 2009
    Posts: 435

    Blue Moon Garage
    Member

    I have Grundy and they would cover this.
     
    GlassThamesDoug and Sharpone like this.
  10. Another reason to like clutch fans. These limit maximum fan speed to about 4K RPM. Yeah, they're hard to package in some cars, but worth it IMO if you can make one fit.
     
  11. goldmountain
    Joined: Jun 12, 2016
    Posts: 4,655

    goldmountain

    I purchased the Zip's water pump setup ages ago when everything was cast iron along with the water pump thinking that the aluminum version would look better. Newer isn't always better.
     
    Sharpone likes this.
  12. Unkl Ian
    Joined: Mar 29, 2001
    Posts: 13,419

    Unkl Ian

    The Aluminum pump was killed by the broken fan.
    Agreed, a cast iron pump would have stayed together, most likely.
     
    Andy, Sharpone and Balljoint like this.
  13. 49ratfink
    Joined: Feb 8, 2004
    Posts: 19,247

    49ratfink
    Member
    from California

    had one let go in my old 56 BelAir. sent it right through the hood so I hammer and dollied it into the shape of one louver :)
     
    Sharpone, X-cpe and AccurateMike like this.
  14. Balljoint
    Joined: Dec 3, 2021
    Posts: 218

    Balljoint
    Member

    Several years ago at our airport we had a three blade propeller assembly show up that was off of a King Air. One of the blades had broken off within two or three inches of the base. These propeller blades weigh roughly 25 lbs. or so static, so you can imagine what the centrifugal weight is when they are spinning. The pilot told a co-worker how the prop blade separated from the prop hub during a flight and in the few seconds it took him to shut down that engine it almost shook the engine off the wing. They were fortunate that the blade didn’t go through the aircraft and instead sailed off into the air. If it had gone through the aircraft it likely would have brought the plane down. On a good note, I’ve never seen or heard of another instance of this happening in general aviation, many failsafe measures are in place to stop these kinds of things from happening.
    As others have said previously, I believe Squirrel is right on the money in his analysis.
    This fan blade is a similar situation to the propeller on a smaller scale. One reason why I always try to stay out of the line of sight of fans when timing an engine or performing some other similar task. The chances are slim, but as your experience shows, it can happen.
     
    49ratfink, 41 GMC K-18 and Sharpone like this.
  15. 69fury
    Joined: Feb 24, 2009
    Posts: 1,618

    69fury
    Member

    Returning to work from lunch one nice day, I had 2 blades and their portion of the hub leave the 5 blade fan on my Fury's 318. The imbalance was incredible.

    The chunk lopped the bottom corner off my battery just big enough to allow a slow drip to overcome the surface tension of the acid.

    After removing the corner of the battery, it karate chopped the factory steel brake line crossing the top of the frame, flattening it a good bit, but not closing it off.

    Removed the fan and drove it home from work that summer day-all highway, so it cooled fine. considered myself lucky.

    -rick
     
    41 GMC K-18, Balljoint and Sharpone like this.
  16. Happydaze
    Joined: Aug 21, 2009
    Posts: 2,097

    Happydaze
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    So the blade that let loose wasn't the only problem? Looks like the whole thing was soon to go off. Someone pulled the pin out of that grenade! The small bang was big enough....

    Chris
     
    Unkl Ian likes this.
  17. Late seeing this thread. But as the old HAMB metallurgist, I can tell you that is a fatigue crack on the missing fan blade. You can see the basically smooth elliptical shape of the fatigue crack propagation in the dark area. 100% classic fatigue crack appearance. If you follow the propagation back to the initiation point you might find a stress concentration of some sort. That may take magnification better than a simple internet picture. The clean rough area is the final stage overload fracture, where the remaining portion exceeded the tensile strength. Technical term is dimple rupture, which is a ductile overload fracture.
     
    loudbang, 05snopro440, PhilA and 5 others like this.
  18. Sharpone
    Joined: Jul 25, 2022
    Posts: 1,472

    Sharpone
    Member

    What would cause the stress concentration?, poor design, overspeeding ?
    Thanks
    Dan
     
  19. Stress concentration could be almost anything. Rough spot on the surface, a scratch or machining mark on the surface, a small defect in the material. Basically anything that makes the localized stress in that area higher. But remember that a fatigue crack is below yield stress propagation. It takes many thousands of cycles (several hundreds of thousands typically) to initiate and propagate the crack. A fan flexes as it reacts with the air on the blade, plus it also has the centrifugal force pulling it. Lots of source for stress.
     
    05snopro440, Unkl Ian and Sharpone like this.
  20. Sharpone
    Joined: Jul 25, 2022
    Posts: 1,472

    Sharpone
    Member

    Thanks
    Dan
     
    Balljoint likes this.
  21. Unkl Ian
    Joined: Mar 29, 2001
    Posts: 13,419

    Unkl Ian


    Google: Stress Riser.
     
    Sharpone likes this.
  22. 41 GMC K-18
    Joined: Jun 27, 2019
    Posts: 4,186

    41 GMC K-18
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    Truly amazing account of gear box failure that caused the prop to slice through the belly of the aircraft, shortly after take off. Major decompression and no one was hurt!
    This event happened on June 8th, 1983, the plane made a dramatic landing in Seattle, the footage of it is incredible!
    Check out this incredible story on YouTube.
    This is just a screenshot, so you can look it up with a web search.
    Thanks from Dennis.
    IMG_1255.jpg
     
    Balljoint and Sharpone like this.
  23. Sharpone
    Joined: Jul 25, 2022
    Posts: 1,472

    Sharpone
    Member

    I understand stress risers, but unless the OP nicked or damaged the fan during installation any stress riser that caused the failure should be the manufacturer’s responsibility. If the OP exceeded the recommended RPM of the fan I can see that starting the crack. The OP had approximately 4000 miles on the fan, surely that amount of run time shouldn’t have approached enough cycles to cause a failure. I would think that 100,000 miles would be an absolute minimum before failure. Good design and engineering practices should dictate a fairly high factor of safety to guard against such a failure. Hopefully the manufacturer stands behind the fan.
    Dan
     
    Unkl Ian likes this.
  24. PhilA
    Joined: Sep 6, 2018
    Posts: 2,075

    PhilA
    Member
    1. Hydro Tech

    I would expect the process of manufacturing that fan to be either a single or two-step process; if two, a flat sheet is cut out and then thrown into a stamper to give it the fan profile, flung into a bin, hung up for paint, baked and boxed.

    Doubtful the stamp-cut edges are feathered, so any slice like that will cause small score marks to be present on the edge, along with a curved top shear edge and slightly rough break on the back.

    Gentle cleaning of the paint on the same area of an unbroken blade will show how much care went into the production of the piece.
     
    Sharpone likes this.
  25. Unkl Ian
    Joined: Mar 29, 2001
    Posts: 13,419

    Unkl Ian

    ...are often over ruled by Bean Counters, who know nothing about design or engineering.
     
    Sharpone likes this.
  26. I know a guy that this happened to. Just barely got to keep his arm when the surgeries were over. Good reminder for all of us to inspect old fans.... With the engine off.
     
  27. 05snopro440
    Joined: Mar 15, 2011
    Posts: 2,116

    05snopro440
    Member

    My failure analysis background agrees.
     
    loudbang and Sharpone like this.

Share This Page

Register now to get rid of these ads!

Archive

Copyright © 1995-2021 The Jalopy Journal: Steal our stuff, we'll kick your teeth in. Terms of Service. Privacy Policy.

Atomic Industry
Forum software by XenForo™ ©2010-2014 XenForo Ltd.