Actually they do not. There are 2 sizes. Depending on wether the car is a Roadmaster, Century, Special, or a Super.
What "Zman" said. More specifically, the Special and the Century share the smaller, more narrow body as opposed to the wider, longer "big-body" Super and Roadmaster -cars.
The next Question is which one fits the 57 Chevy without modifying and what are the measurments or features that distinguish them from one another.
The smaller grill has a shape that more closely matches the shape of the bumper and the hood tie bar making for a neater fit and finish.