what should i get? model a coupe or 59 edsel

Good choice. Whoever did that lime green treatment should be slapped,lol.

However, in your original post you didn't tell us you already had a Hudson and an Edsel or what the price of the Edsel or A were.

 

Model "A"s can be bought by the dozens are built in your garage with brand new parts. But. not everyone can have a 59 Edsel, which by the way was just a different design for a 59 Ford. So go for the Edsel!